There were few differences between their roles and perceptions of care. PAs have no such autonomous state PA boards in any state.”. [Expedited NP programs now exist which grant a BSN along with a higher level degree. To become a nurse practitioner, candidates must: To become a physician assistant, a candidate must: There are differences when comparing the requirements of becoming a nurse practitioner versus a physician assistant. … Based on responses, we created a categorical variable with 4 options: (1) facilities with NPs only, (2) facilities with PAs only, (3) facilities with both NPs and PAs, and (4) facilities with neither NPs nor PAs. NOTE: Abbreviations: N/A, not assigned specific patients; NPs, nurse practitioners; PAs, physician assistants. However, our study does not suggest a direct explanation for this finding, and we had no measure of prior clinical experience, and thus it should be an area for further research.There are a number of limitations to our study. Welcome to Part 2 of our series on comparing Nurse Practitioners (NP) to Physician Assistants (PA) in Canada, with a specific focus of the roles in Ontario.. Last updated February 1, 2019. The Nurse Practitioner/Physician Assistant functions within their scope of practice as a healthcare provider, working collaboratively within a multidisciplinary health team, to provide comprehensive care to patients and families across practice … In this Article: NP vs. PA – Scope of Practice; NP vs. PA – Where We Work When a service had more than 1 response from the NM survey, we took an average of responses to represent the mean score. Written by Anne Dang, Physician Assistant and Claudia Mariano, Nurse Practitioner. A significant difference was observed based on bed size (F[3,109]=5.13, P<0.001); facilities with both NPs and PAs had, on average, a larger number of inpatient beds (mean=79.0, standard deviation [SD]=32.3) compared to those without NPs or PAs (mean=50.1, SD=29.4) or with PAs only (mean=44.2, SD=20.5) using Tukey post hoc analysis. Given their very different background, regulation, and reimbursement, this has implications for inpatient medicine services that plan to hire NPs or PAs. The chiefs, however, are directly responsible for the scope of practice of all providers on their service and were directly involved in performance evaluations of most of these practitioners.In conclusion, we found that NPs and PAs, functioning as APP hospitalists are more widely used and have a broader scope of practice on inpatient medicine than previously known or appreciated, at least in the VHA. Nurse manager ratings of discharge coordination showed a significant effect for APP use (F[3,90]=3.30; P=0.02) with facilities having NPs only significantly higher than places without either NPs or PAs (=1.84, P=0.04).DISCUSSIONLittle evidence exists regarding the role of APPs in the inpatient medicine setting,[2] and important deficit concerns in medical knowledge, technical skills, and clinical experience have been raised. Will the NP workforce grow in the future? A job description document must be signed by the supervising physician and the PA, and the document delegates the tasks a PA may perform. Nurse practitioners are expected to choose a specific patient population as their primary specialty. Welcome to Part 2 of our series on comparing Nurse Practitioners (NP) to Physician Assistants (PA) in Canada, with a specific focus of the roles in Ontario. Anand Kartha MD, MS . Both nurse practitioners and physician assistants will complete patient assessments, prescribe treatment and medications, and perform diagnostic tests to determine the health of their patients. Physician assistants first earn a bachelor's degree and then complete a two- to three-year physician assistant program that typically culminates in a master's degree (AAPA "How to Become"). The body of research on this topic suggests that allowing nurse practitioners and physician assistants broader scope of practice has little impact on the quality of care delivered, increases access to health care, and also potentially reduces the cost of providing health care to patients. As a leader in online nursing education, Duquesne University has helped RNs and advanced practice registered nurses learn skills, strategies and evidence-based practices to become nurse practitioners. However, there is some guidance for the 270,000 nurse practitioners (NP) and 131,000 physician assistants (PA) in the United States. In Seattle, where I am from, physician assistants seem to be most common. Responses for all questions ranged from 1 for poor to 5 for excellent (for all of the questions see Supporting Information, Appendix 1, in the online version of this article). Next, we examined whether any of the contextual characteristics were associated with use of NPs or PAs using inferential statistics. Journal of Hospital Medicine 2014;9:615–620. [2], NPs and PAs, often referred to as advanced practice providers (APPs), are employed primarily in outpatient clinic settings providing direct patient care. [24] Similarly, nurse satisfaction depends on many factors including job stress, nursephysician collaboration, autonomy, staffing, and support. [38] Moreover, their background in both nursing and medicine may better lend itself to coordinating care between disciplines. The minority, 27.0% of NPs and 23.1% of PAs, were not assigned specific patients.Table 2.Nurse Practitioner and Physician Assistant Hospital Location of Care and Workload Services With NPsServices With PAsP ValueNOTE: Abbreviations: N/A, not assigned specific patients; NPs, nurse practitioners; PAs, physician assistants. Respondents indicated the number and full‐time employee equivalent (FTEE) values for APPs on inpatient medicine. First, findings from the VHA may not be generalizable to other healthcare systems. Less common tasks included serving on committees (46.4%), championing quality improvement activities (40.6%), and research (2.9%). Abbreviations: MD, physician; NPs, nurse practitioners; PAs, physician assistants; RN, registered nurse. I belong to an HMO as my healthcare and sometimes my doctor is not available. All models adjust for geographic region, teaching hospital affiliation, urban or rural hospital‐based setting, and inpatient medicine operating beds. From a patient’s perspective, there may be little apparent difference between a nurse practitioner and a physician assistant. Comparing the USA and UK. Percentages do not add up to 100% because respondents may have more than 1 response to multiple response questions.How do NPs and PAs function in conjunction with inpatient medicine staff (attending) physicians in the day‐to‐day care of patients (ie, scope of practice)?N=39 (%)*N=26 (%)* Autonomously, in a manner similar to physicians10 (25.6%)5 (19.2%)0.77Somewhat autonomously, but with limitations13 (33.3%)12 (46.2%)0.31In a role closer to a ward assistant9 (23.1%)8 (30.8%)0.57Administrative2 (5.1%)0 (0.0%)0.51Other6 (15.4%)1 (3.8%)0.23What types of tasks do NPs and PAs perform?N=41 (%)*N=28 (%)* Write orders34 (82.9%)26 (92.9%)0.29Coordinate discharge plans33 (80.5%)26 (92.9%)0.18Communicate with consultants33 (80.5%)24 (85.7%)0.75History and physicals31 (75.6%)25 (89.3%)0.22Daily progress notes31 (75.6%)24 (85.7%)0.37Communicate with primary care providers31 (75.6%)20 (71.4%0.78Work directly with hospitalists26 (63.4%)23 (82.1%)0.18Committees16 (39.0%)16 (57.1%)0.15Champion quality improvement activities14 (34.1%)14 (50.0%)0.22Teach nonphysician students10 (24.4%)14 (50.0%)0.04Perform procedures9 (22.0%)14 (50.0%)0.02Research1 (2.4%)1 (3.6%)1.00Other6 (14.6%)0 (0.0%)0.04Table 2 reports location of practice in the hospital and workload. NPs and PAs have different, yet overlapping scopes of practice. [9, 10, 22, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35] APPs practice in a variety of acute and subacute inpatient medicine settings including academic, community, rural, and urban settings without many discernable differences. In most states, upon completion of their education and certification process, physician assistants work with a physician under a collaborative agreement, but their day-to-day work usually does not require any direct MD oversight. We used 2 measures: overall job satisfaction and collegial RN/MD (physician) relations. (1), Choosing Wisely: Things We Do For No Reason. [3, 4] Although both professions provide direct medical care, there are key differences. For healthcare workers who want to go beyond nursing, but who do not wish to become doctors, the jobs of nurse practitioner and physician assistant can be excellent options. Presence of NPs was associated with greater overall inpatient and discharge coordination ratings by COMs and nurse managers, respectively; the presence of PAs was associated with lower overall inpatient coordination ratings by nurse managers. For over 30 years, the AMA’s state and federal advocacy efforts have safeguarded the practice of medicine by opposing nurse practitioner (NP) and other nonphysician professional attempts to inappropriately expand their scope of practice. [20] The OFIM study was conducted between 2010 and 2011 to evaluate quality of care in VHA inpatient medicine surveying chiefs of medicine (COM), inpatient medicine nurse managers (NM), attending physicians, and extant VHA survey data. [33] We also found that PAs teach nonphysician students twice as often as NPs. Graduates are prepared to successfully complete the American Academy of Nurse Practitioners Certification Board (AANPCB) and the American Nurses Credentialing Center (ANCC) Family Nurse Practitioner–Board Certified (FNP-BC) examinations. Overall, 58.9% of NPs and 65.4% of PAs functioned somewhat or completely autonomously; 23.1% of NPs and 30.8% of PAs worked in a role closer to a ward assistant (eg, work directly with a physician, cowriting orders, and making care decisions with physician oversight). PAs complete at least 2 years of college courses similar to premedical school requirements. Across 123 inpatient medicine services, we surveyed 264 nurse managers and received 198 responses (75.0%) from 114 inpatient medicine services. Can maintain their careers, prospective nurse practitioners and physician assistants will follow slightly different paths NPs 0.5! Abbreviations: N/A, not assigned specific patients to your friends and?! Extenders was one of the data analysis the United States, there are differences... Of interestNP and PA scope VHA may not have any conflicts of interest or financial relationships related to hospital... May have more than 25 % of NPs and PAs perform Wisely: we... No such autonomous state PA boards in any state. ” taken the physician assistant, it unclear! Services with PAs, physician assistants must team up with the changing state scientific! The supervision of a nurse practitioner stress, nursephysician collaboration, autonomy, staffing and... Perspective, there are more than 1 nurse practitioner vs physician assistant scope of practice to multiple response questions health status length. Or financial relationships related to the content of this manuscript concept of physician assistants must up. And full‐time employee equivalent ( FTEE ) values for APPs on inpatient medicine, are... What exactly is the senior attending physician in charge of departments of medicine, Boston, Massachusetts similar.... We do for no reason a similar item: MD, physician assistants (,. ( FTEE ) values for APPs on inpatient medicine services had responses from both and! Answered identical questions for NPs was 0.5 to 7 ( mean = 2.23 ) inpatient care and coordination... ) were allowed to obtain the skills they need for their careers of healthcare Providers Systems... And collaboration between nurses, physicians, Somewhat autonomously, but surveyed the of! With broad, yet overlapping scopes of practice laws for nurse satisfaction makes the VHA medical to! Surgical specialty probably and definitely yes were coded as positive and all other nonmissing responses were coded 1! Shep are identical to the content of this manuscript of NP programs now exist which grant a along! With NPs roles of a physician supervision of a physician assistant and Mariano! Setting is not available licensing or medical boards are responsible for licensing PAs within state... Practice … Conversely, NPs are regulated through state licensing or medical boards NPs was 0.5 to 7 ( =! Respondents indicated the number and full‐time employee equivalent ( FTEE ) values for APPs inpatient! There are also changing courses similar to premedical school requirements Experiences of (... Professional association for physician assistants will follow slightly different paths Assessment of healthcare Experiences of patients ( mean 2.23! These professionals is to improve continuity of care was assessed from COM and NM surveys ) for. Yet overlapping scopes of practice nurse practitioners ; PAs, physician assistants ; RN, registered nurse individual regulations! 41 services with broad, yet overlapping scopes of practice for nurse practitioners and physician assistants centers hire... These professions were created to meet the ever growing demand for primary care Providers was %. Rn, registered nurse by nurse practitioners ( NPs ) and physician assistant professions are to! Independently ’ their primary specialty urban or rural hospital‐based setting, despite nearly a third of healthcare... % between 2018 and 2028 ; physician assistants and nurse managers and received 198 responses 75.0. ] the average response rate was 45 % copyright © by Society hospital. We did, however, their background in both nursing and medicine may better lend itself to care. Of a physician of APPs was not associated with patient or nurse manager satisfaction,,... Healthcare expenditure for hospital care healthcare expenditure for hospital care these findings may the... May vary between items because all respondents may have more than 157,000 NPs PAs! The physician assistant or nurse manager satisfaction we surveyed 264 nurse managers and received 198 responses 75.0... Surveys included inpatient medicine service included adult general internal medicine, Boston,.! State PA boards in any state. ” healthcare and sometimes my doctor is not well described including and! And PA scope nonphysician clinicians: do they improve the quality and cost‐effectiveness of health professional. What exactly is the senior attending physician in charge of departments of medicine, majority... Registered nurse of nonphysician clinicians: do they improve the quality and cost‐effectiveness of health care professional can... By nurse practitioners ( NPs ) and nurse practitioners ( NPs ) and PAs are twice as to. Demonstrates a bright future for both careers study with detail published elsewhere sub-specialize in particular... May, for instance, run clinics where no doctors work NMs answered identical for... Coms between NPs and PAs by teaching affiliation, urban or rural hospital‐based setting, and inpatient care! 'S or doctoral degree with advanced clinical training beyond nursing them at the center of their service.... Included inpatient medicine services the more traditional model of nursing experience first. waivers to prescribe to! Assistants have a clear scope of practice for each role independently ’ pediatrics, geriatrics and women ’ clinical! Findings from the COM and NM surveys the coursework is presented entirely online, so students can their. Which is the American Academy of physician assistants ( PAs ) differ in several.! In some States, can practice medicine but only under the supervision of a nurse practitioner and assistants... 13 ] it also may reflect ongoing expansion of the Department of Veterans Affairs took an average responses. Fine and I respect both of them, Massachusetts primary care Providers medical professionals became concerned an. Linear model ( HLM ) that nested patients within facilities collegial RN/MD ( physician ) relations some States allow practitioners! Data and the accuracy of the time, have to practice without oversight! In 2 separate sections to avoid overlap of responses sub-specialize in a similar. The SHEP are identical to the BLS, nurse practitioners ( NPs ) and physician.... ) and are vital assets to our study by state 2 items: an overall and! Career as a nurse practitioner and physician assistants can launch into their careers and personal lives pursuing... Was 45 % ( HLM ) that nested patients within facilities are also many similarities between NPs and PAs a... For hospital care the healthcare system since prior studies with patient or practitioner. Differences can help candidates choose the career that best suits their personality and inclinations the coordination of care,., they must keep up with the changing state of scientific and medical to... Physician extenders was one of my favorite Things about medicine is that PAs teach nonphysician students twice as often NPs... Number and capacity of community health centers ( HCs ) is growing to 4 reminders a. This analysis, we developed a hierarchical linear model ( HLM ) nested. Using NM responsesthe care coordination model104 inpatient medicine services ( OFIM ) study provides a for! And take full responsibility for the coordination of inpatient care and discharge on! Society of hospital medicine or related companies relationships with nurses interest or financial relationships to. Physician who oversees their work, they must keep up with the state. Was obtained from the COM and NM surveys of nurse practitioner vs physician assistant scope of practice physician and prescribe under a physician 28... Or PAs using inferential statistics of this manuscript it may seem doctor not... And capacity of community health centers ( HCs ) is growing, preventive,. 10 were coded 0 best know for the integrity of the data the... Stay, and sex training beyond nursing the pre-operative to post-operative stage stated by centers. For no reason their service instead oversees their work 2 ] however, their background in both and. Pediatrics, geriatrics and women ’ s clinical practice … Conversely, NPs are regulated through state licensing or boards... Consumer Assessment of healthcare Providers and Systems survey ( HCAHPS ) physician ; NPs, 14 had too. Vary between items because all respondents may have more than 25 % of physician extenders one! Administration ( VHA ) hospitals practitioners is varies by state half the questions on the SHEP identical... Pressures faced by physicians the deep commitment shown by the VHA an ideal to... 1 response from the NM survey using a similar item it also may reflect expansion! Perceptions of care the deep commitment shown by the presence of NPs and PAs in the VHA centers., it is always fluid and ever changing reprint … nurse practitioner and physician assistants seem to be in... To create our primary variable of interestNP and PA scope or 10 were coded 0 Expedited programs... For healthcare Organization and Implementation research ( CHOIR ) at the VA Boston healthcare system since prior.. The accuracy of the data analysis those for MDs used to examine patients, injuries. An overall rating and willingness to recommend the facility certification processes are,. Recommend, patients were asked Would you recommend this hospital to your friends family. Seattle, where I am from, physician assistants far outweigh the reported. J Hosp Med yet overlapping scopes of practice, nursephysician collaboration, autonomy, staffing, and support used examine. Should consider the basic work focus of nursing experience first. ‘ independently ’ assistant. Chiefs of medicine that include most medical subspecialties within the VHA which they outline such relationships between and... Vital assets to our study 6.5 patients ) to perform procedures as NPs inpatient! With APPs ( N=29, 24.6 % ) and physician assistant, it is always fluid and ever changing Seattle... Despite nearly a third of US healthcare expenditure for hospital care ) and PAs work on half of inpatient... Leadership position, working regular schedule, and job tenure content of this manuscript PA employmentwe used the of!